HiBob vs Personio vs Workday: The top choice for 2025

Choosing the right HR platform can make or break an HR team’s experience. You need a system that handles your core HR needs while actually making work easier—not adding to your to-do list. If you’re comparing HiBob, Personio, and Workday, you’re looking at three established platforms with very different approaches.

Each one serves a specific type of company best. HiBob delivers a modern experience teams enjoy using, with automated workflows that save hours of manual work. Personio focuses on European SMEs with strong compliance needs. Workday brings enterprise-level power to large organizations. To understand which platform is right for your organization, let’s break down what really matters so you can pick the platform that fits your team.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed here are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the company. Prospective users are encouraged to conduct their own research to make the best decision for their organization.

Key takeaways: HiBob vs Personio vs Workday

• All three platforms handle core HR well, but they’re very different in user experience and total cost
• HiBob drives high adoption with its social media-style interface that people engage with daily
• Personio works well for European companies needing GDPR compliance and localized support
• Workday offers unified HR and finance data for enterprises needing cross-department insights
• HiBob scales effortlessly from dozens to thousands of people without requiring migration

HiBob vs Personio vs Workday: Overview

What is HiBob?

HiBob is a modern HR platform built for growing companies that need more than basic HR tools. You’ll get integrated performance management, compensation planning, and workforce analytics that work together to make your life easier. You’ll have the flexibility to customize your workflows easily—no coding required.

What are HiBob’s key features?

• Core HR with automated workflows: Simplify your processes with streamlined onboarding, time-off, and documentation
• 360-degree performance reviews: Align individual goals to team and company objectives
• HiBob’s Compensation Management: Get support for multiple currencies and global pay cycles for international teams
• HiBob’s People Analytics: Have real-time data at your fingertips at all times, with customizable reports for data-driven decisions
• HiBob’s Workforce Planning tool: Map and track current and future positions to plan strategic growth

What are HiBob’s pros and cons?

Pros:

• “The high degree of customization in Bob is very impressive” – verified review
• “I love that Hibob is customizable to our business needs” – verified review
• “Bob allows me to see everyone’s timesheets, holiday bookings, absence in different ways” – verified review
• “Whatever data I need for employees, I can easily put in a report” – verified review
• “The tools used were great to help us track everything” – verified review
• “The interface is simple and user-friendly” – verified review

Cons:

• “I don’t like that I can’t speak to someone easily at HiBob” – verified review
• “Sometimes there is a new feature released and the old one was much more valuable” – verified review

What is Personio?

Personio is an HRIS designed for European SMEs that need strong compliance and localization. You’ll find it handles the complete employee lifecycle from hiring to offboarding. It’s great for GDPR compliance and document management, including e-signatures.

What are Personio’s key features?

• Core HR with centralized data: Employee records, time-off, and document management in one place
• Performance management: Ongoing feedback and 360-degree reviews for ongoing development
• Talent management: Covers the full employee journey from hiring to offboarding
• Integration marketplace: 100+ vendor integrations including Lattice and Greenhouse
• Automated payroll: Covers UK, Ireland, and Germany, including Germany’s particularly tricky requirements

(This article includes platform features that reflect the information available on the Personio website as of the publication date.)

What are Personio’s pros and cons?

Pros:

• “Personio excels at centralizing all employee data, which dramatically streamlines everything” – verified review
• “I can easily plan my 20-hour work weeks and adjust my schedule when needed” – verified review
• “The interface is simple and user-friendly, and requesting time off takes just a few clicks” – verified review

Cons:

• “Reporting suite can be somewhat cumbersome for generating simple, ad-hoc reports” – verified review
• “The platform tends to be very slow and non-responsive at times” – verified review
• “SSO was a core feature I needed but they told me it’s not part of my package” – verified review

<<Compare HiBob vs. Personio – See which fits your business best>>

What is Workday?

Workday is a cloud-native enterprise HRIS that combines HR, finance, and planning in one system. Large organizations get deep analytics across departments and extensive configuration options to match your enterprise needs.

What are Workday’s key features?

• HCM suite: Covers the complete hire-to-retire lifecycle for enterprises
• Global payroll: Native support in 5 countries plus 100+ via partners
• Advanced talent management: Performance and succession planning at scale
• Skills Cloud AI: AI-powered skills foundation for talent strategies
• Mobile-first interface: Intuitive user experience across all devices

(This article includes platform features that reflect the information available on the Workday website as of the publication date.)

What are Workday’s pros and cons?

Pros:

• “Workday offers fantastic reporting and dashboard capabilities which allow for data-driven decisions” – verified review
• “Workday integrates well with other systems and makes Workday the hub for employee data” – verified review
• “Platform early adopters were fascinated that they could see profile updates in real time” – verified review

Cons:

• “Workday is an expensive platform, so it may not be a good fit for smaller companies” – verified review
• “The navigation can be confusing, especially for new users” – verified review
• “Finding past pay slips or editing certain personal information can feel unnecessarily complicated” – verified review

<<Compare HiBob vs. Workday – See which fits your business best>>

HiBob vs Personio vs Workday: Detailed comparison and key differences

Performance management and reviews

HiBob links performance reviews to actual company goals and salary decisions, so everything connects rather than living in separate systems. Personio keeps things more traditional—you get regular feedback cycles that European companies often prefer. Workday has all the bells and whistles for planning who moves up in your company, but you’ll need serious training to use all of the features.

The big question is how much complexity you want. Workday packs in features most companies probably won’t need. Personio works fine if you just need the basics done right. HiBob gives you great balance, with features that are powerful but manageable. 

User interface and mobile experience

The easier a platform is to use, the more your team will engage with it. Personio gets the job done, though users report the web version can be slow and the mobile app has limited functionality. Workday looks slick and professional on mobile, but there’s so much going on that new users might feel lost.

HiBob goes in a different direction, with an interface that looks and feels like social media. People actually check it daily because it reminds them of apps they already know and like, including features like Kudos and Shoutouts that keep teams connected. That kind of familiarity makes a huge difference in getting your team on board.

Core HR and employee database management

When it comes to storing and organizing employee info, each platform has its own style. Workday connects HR data to finance and planning, which can be great if you’re a big company that needs everything talking to each other. Personio keeps all your documents and signatures in one place, making document management simple and organized.

HiBob lets you build your own workflows quickly—you won’t even need to call IT to help. You can set things up to match how your company works, whether that’s approval chains, automatic reminders, or whatever else you need. It’s more flexible than Personio’s document focus and simpler than Workday’s everything-connected approach.

Pricing and implementation

Comparing prices across different platforms isn’t easy. Personio doesn’t share prices publicly but they’re aimed at smaller companies, and their support team helps you get up and running fast. Workday will cost you $34-42 per person each month, but keep in mind that you’ll also pay 150-200% of that annual cost just for setup, plus consultants to keep it running.

HiBob sits at $16-25 per person monthly and takes about six to eight weeks to get going. HiBob also includes features like performance reviews and compensation planning in that price, rather than charging you extra. 

Learning and development (L and D)

Workday uses AI to figure out what skills everyone in your company has—pretty cool if you’re big enough to need that. HiBob offers Bob Learning as its built-in LMS, plus connects with other learning platforms if you prefer, tying everything to performance and engagement data so you can see the full picture. Personio keeps it simple with basic tracking of who’s done what training.

Think about what you actually need. If you’re a huge company mapping skills across departments, Workday makes sense. Growing companies often prefer HiBob’s flexibility to use their built-in solution or plug in their favorite tools. Smaller teams usually find Personio’s simple approach covers their needs.

Time and attendance tracking

Personio makes time tracking straightforward—people clock in, vacation balances update automatically, and managers approve with one click. HiBob adds nice touches like a calendar showing who’s out when, and your team can clock in right from Slack or Teams. Workday takes it up a notch with location tracking and automatic absence handling.

Pick what matches your reality. If you need basic time tracking, Personio works great. HiBob’s Time and Attendance feature helps teams see who’s available at a glance. Workday’s fancy features make sense if you’re managing people across multiple locations.

Payroll processing and integration

Here’s where geography really matters. Personio handles payroll directly in UK, Ireland, and Germany—they’re especially good with Germany’s complicated rules. Surprisingly, Workday only does payroll natively in five countries despite being the enterprise choice, using partners everywhere else.

HiBob runs payroll in-house for the UK and US, and partners with top payroll companies around the world. This means you can pick the best payroll provider for each country instead of being stuck with one system. It’s more flexible than Personio’s three-country limit or Workday’s heavy reliance on partners.

Recruitment and applicant tracking (ATS)

HiBob integrates with whichever ATS you prefer through its integration marketplace, while providing workforce planning tools to figure out what roles you’ll need. Personio covers the whole hiring process from posting jobs to onboarding, and connects with tools like Greenhouse if you need more power.

Workday includes recruiting in its big bundle, but some big companies still use separate recruiting tools anyway. Your choice depends on whether you want everything built in, the freedom to pick your favorite tools, or the enterprise package deal.

Employee onboarding and offboarding

Getting new people started right can make a huge difference. Workday automates everything—IT setup, equipment orders, system access—which is thorough, but can feel like overkill for smaller teams. Personio focuses on getting rid of paperwork with digital forms and e-signatures that work well.

HiBob lets you create an onboarding process that feels personal without spending weeks setting it up. You can build automated workflows that match how you actually welcome new people. While Workday connects more systems and Personio focuses on handling documents, HiBob finds the balance between making things automatic and keeping them human.

Reporting and analytics

HiBob gives you real-time HR reports you can easily understand, including turnover trends, engagement scores, and performance patterns. Workday goes all out with analytics covering HR, finance, operations, and probably what you had for lunch, but you’ll need serious skills to set it up and use it. Personio’s analytics are more basic—fine for simple reports but not much else.

Growing companies find HiBob’s focused approach just right. You get the insights you need without the complexity of Workday or the limitations of Personio’s basic reporting.

Easily connect to the tools your HR team uses every day

Request a Demo

Comparison summary: HiBob vs Personio vs Workday

1. HiBob

• Designed for: Growing companies (50-500 people)
• Performance reviews: 360-degree with goal alignment
• Mobile experience: Instagram-like interface
• Global support: Multi-national with multiple languages
• Workflow automation: No-code configuration
• Time tracking: Clock in/out with Slack/Teams integration
• Payroll: UK native, global via partners
• Analytics: Real-time HR-focused insights
• Marketplace: Replaces multiple point solutions

2. Personio

• Designed for: European SMEs (10-2,000 people)
• Performance reviews: Ongoing feedback and 360-degree
• Mobile experience: Limited functionality
• Global support: 70+ countries, Europe focus
• Workflow automation: Cross-application workflows
• Time tracking: Time clock with vacation calculations
• Payroll: UK, Ireland, Germany only
• Analytics: Basic reporting capabilities
• Marketplace: 100+ vendor integrations

3. Workday

• Designed for: Large enterprises (500+ people)
• Performance reviews: Advanced with succession planning
• Mobile experience: Mobile-first professional design
• Global support: Five countries native, 100+ via partners
• Workflow automation: Enterprise-grade configuration
• Time tracking: Geofencing and automated absence
• Payroll: Five countries native, partners elsewhere
• Analytics: Cross-department unified insights
• Marketplace: Part of a larger enterprise ecosystem

How do I choose between HiBob, Personio, and Workday?

Start by honestly assessing your company’s size and trajectory. If you’re growing fast, HiBob’s scalability and quick implementation make it a great choice. The platform grows with you without requiring massive reinvestment or migration headaches down the road.

Consider your geographic focus next: 

• HiBob works brilliantly for global teams with its multi-language support and currency handling.
• European companies, especially those in Germany, will appreciate Personio’s GDPR expertise and localized payroll. 
• Workday suits massive multinationals who need enterprise-grade everything, though you’ll pay premium prices for capabilities you might not use.

Think about your team’s technical capabilities and patience for learning curves. HiBob’s no-code workflows and intuitive interface mean your HR team can manage everything independently. Personio offers solid support but requires more traditional HR knowledge. Workday? Plan on hiring consultants or dedicating full-time staff to system management.

What mistakes should I avoid when comparing HRIS platforms?

Choosing an HR platform is a big decision, and it’s easy to get distracted by flashy features or big names. The key is focusing on what your team will actually use day-to-day and what fits your company’s size and workforce planning needs.

Common mistakes to avoid:

• Being intrigued by features you won’t use: AI-powered skills mapping might sound amazing, but does your 75-person team really need it?
• Underestimating total costs: Look beyond monthly fees to implementation costs, training time, and whether you’ll need consultants
• Choosing based on company size alone: A platform perfect for enterprises might overwhelm a growing company, while SME solutions might limit your growth
• Ignoring user experience: The fanciest features mean nothing if your team finds the platform too complicated to use
• Focusing on today without considering tomorrow: Pick a platform that can grow with you rather than one you’ll outgrow in two years

Finding the right balance is key. You want something powerful enough to support your growth but intuitive enough for daily use, including performance management that your team will actually embrace. For many growing companies, HiBob offers exactly that—robust features wrapped in an interface that makes sense. Don’t forget to evaluate the HR analytics capabilities to ensure you can measure success.

Why HiBob is the best choice for growing companies

HiBob strikes the perfect balance between power and usability. You get enterprise-level features like 360-degree reviews and multi-currency compensation management, wrapped in an interface people genuinely enjoy using. Its workforce planning capabilities mean you’re investing in your company’s future.

HiBob’s flexibility sets it apart from both Personio and Workday. You can build custom workflows matching your exact needs without coding knowledge or consultants. As your company grows, HiBob adapts with you—it’s easy to add locations, currencies, or processes.

Most importantly, HiBob focuses on what matters: keeping your people engaged and productive. While Personio handles compliance and Workday manages massive complexity, HiBob helps you build the kind of culture where talented people want to stay and grow. With features that support employee engagement, you create an environment where teams thrive. 

FAQs about HiBob vs Personio vs Workday

What is the difference between HiBob and Personio?

HiBob offers a more modern, engagement-focused experience with its social media-style interface and broader global capabilities. While Personio excels for European SMEs with strong GDPR compliance and German payroll, HiBob scales better internationally with multi-language support and currency handling. HiBob also includes performance and compensation tools that Personio treats as add-ons.

What is the difference between HiBob and Workday?

The main difference is scale and scope—HiBob provides focused HR tools that are quick to deploy, while Workday offers enterprise-wide systems integration. HiBob is designed for growing companies, offering a social media-style interface and a six to eight week implementation. Workday serves large enterprises with deep functionality across HR, finance, and planning, requiring longer to implement. 

What are the five types of HRIS systems?

The five main HRIS types include operational (basic data management), tactical (recruiting and training), strategic (workforce planning), reporting (analytics-focused), and complete (all-in-one suites). HiBob falls into the complete category, offering everything from core HR to performance management. This integrated approach means you won’t need separate tools for different HR functions.

Which is the best HRM software?

The best HRM software depends on your specific needs, but HiBob consistently ranks highly for growing companies. With its modern interface, quick implementation, and included features like performance management, HiBob delivers exceptional value. The platform replaces multiple tools like Culture Amp or 15Five while costing less than enterprise solutions.

Is Workday similar to BambooHR?

Workday and BambooHR serve opposite ends of the market—Workday targets Fortune 500 enterprises while BambooHR focuses on small businesses. Workday offers deep functionality across HR, finance, and planning but requires significant investment. BambooHR keeps things simple and affordable but lacks advanced features. HiBob sits perfectly between them, offering sophisticated capabilities without enterprise complexity.

Which companies use HiBob?

HiBob serves over 4,200 companies globally, particularly fast-growing organizations between 50-500 people who value culture and engagement. These include tech startups, creative agencies, and modern businesses that want HR software matching their innovative approach. Companies choose HiBob when they’ve outgrown basic tools but don’t need enterprise complexity.